There are no polls currently operating in this sector. Please check back soon. View Poll Archives
Lucas Talks Stereotypes Posted By Joshua on September 9, 1999
Steve got his latest copy of AC and had to share one of the highlights of the interview with Lucas with all of us. Here's his report, and an excerpt from the magazine itself:
I just wanted to pass along this excerpt from Ron Magid's interview with George in the new American Cinematographer. Most of the interview concerns cinematography theory and technology (of course), but this one question was divergent, and George's uninterrupted response is lengthy.
(RM) You've taken some heat for the characterizations of Jar Jar Binks, the Neimodians and Watto, because of what some critics have called racial stereotyping. But isn't it inevitable, when you're creating digital characters from scratch, that you have to draw on different human cultural types? Or is it possible to create 'alien' characters with no human reference points at all?
(GL) Well, this whole issue of racial stereotyping in Episode 1 is completely absurd. That was started by the Los Angeles Times, and they had their own agenda that didn't have anything to do with the movie. I don't think anybody in their right mind - especially not people like the NAACP or the Jewish Anit-Defamiation League - takes those kinds of things seriously. It seems that only the press wants to make something out of it, and they're obviously doing it to sell magazines or newspapers. I don't think they really understand what the definition of a 'stereotype' is! They can't; otherwise, they wouldn't be using (the term) that way.
The (truth) is that they AREN'T stereotypes. The only reason the press tried to make Jar Jar into a stereotype is because they thought he spoke with a Jamaican accent. But the idea was obviously (set forth) by somebody who's never talked to a Jamaican! I mean, if you showed the film to Jamaicans, they wouldn't understand (Jar Jar's speech patterns) any more than somebody who spoke the Queen's English! It's NOT a Jamaican accent; (the dialect) is completely made up. It doesn't even sound like a Jamaican accent. But you know the old racism bit, 'They all look alike?' Well, now, it's becoming 'They all sound alike.' The real racists, actually, are the journalists who are saying that, because they're the ones who can't tell the difference between a Jamaican and a Gungan. The absurdity of this particular thing is that some gay people think Jar Jar is a gay stereotype, but Jamaicans certainly don't think he's a Jamaican stereotype. I mean, he's orange, and he's clumsy in the same way that Buster Keaton, Jerry Lewis or Jim Carey is. He's a comic orange amphibian stereotype!
It's the same with Watto or the Neimodians. The Neimoidians have a Transylvanian accent. And Watto's accent is more like an Italian accent - it's not a real Italian accent, but it certainly isn't anything anti-Semitic. It's not even close to being and Israeli or Arab accent or anything else! It's so absurd! We were building characters. ALL characters are built that way, in all of cinema.
When you're creating a character, you're creating somebody with human personality - otherwise, people aren't going to be interested. You are fashioning characters out of some kind of human personality traits, and a lot of people speak with accents. Yoda speaks with an accent, some people in the films speak with American accents, and some with Norwegian accents. We've done that in all of the movies, and nobody seemed to notice, except with this one - which is just bizarre.
Rebelscum Breast Cancer Awareness Charity Patch Posted By Philip on November 25, 2014: Thanks to everybody that ordered patches. I sent a check for $1,600.00 to the National Breast Cancer Foundation on Monday. While it's not as much as I hoped for, it's still very much appreciated. They will remain for sale in the store for anybody that still wishes to purchase them. Details after the jump.