The Phantom Edits

With all the hype surrounding the Phantom Edits, here is a collection of reviews and essays from Star Wars fans. More essays will appear here during the week, so watch this space!

The Phantom Edit Review (Reviews)

Joshua Griffin from TheForce.Net reviews "The Phantom Edit", the second of 2 fan-edited versions of "The Phantom Menace" (created by an anonymous fan in LA).
June 18, 2001

The Phantom Re-Edit: Episode 1.1 Review (Reviews)

Joshua Griffin from TheForce.Net reviews "The Phantom Re-Edit: Episode 1.1", one of 2 fan-edited versions of "The Phantom Menace" (created back in April 2000 by two guys in New York and a friend in LA).
June 11, 2001

The Phantom Edit - Artistic Rape (Essays)

Chris Knight questions whether the Phantom Editors really understand Star Wars, and whether they made it for an audience that cares less for childish antics and character development.
June 14, 2001

The Phantom Edit - Disrespecting Art (Essays)

Sean Gates gives his reaction to the fan-edits, and asks the fans at which point they stopped respecting an artist's rights.
June 13, 2001

The Phantom Edit - An Edit Too Far (Essays)

Alexander DeLarge gives his reaction to the emergence of the fan-edited versions of "The Phantom Menace", and why he thinks the editors went too far.
June 12, 2001